Today BinPress announced the winners of the component contest. I had the pleasure of being one of the judges.
BinPress had custom-built an internal microsite for us judges where we could download the source code and fill in a form with our judgements. That allowed me to go into the components I was assigned to and really dig into the implementation details. Sorry, but I need to be wagging my finger here, all of the ones I saw had terrible form, little to no code style, the project setup generally was a mess and documentation non-existent.
But nevertheless a ranking was possible – especially because there where other equally important judging factors besides code quality. And so the shining winners are …